The Song of Achilles by Madeline Miller
"The story of Achilles, renowned for his strength, speed and skills at warfare but as told from his ever faithtful friend and companion, Patroclus. Though it had its cliche moments as every romance will, I was pleasantly surprised at how true Miller stayed to the original source of The Illiad. This was a pleasantly surprising and unique take on Homer's epic tale."
⭐⭐⭐
Pros: I liked that it was told from Patroclus POV/Miller stays true to The Illiad, which I greatly appreciated.
Cons: Lots of “burning pleasure” and “fierce, fervor”, all the romance cliches/Achilles arrogance is staggering but that's what Hubris is and that's why it's always the heroes' downfall.
Full Review:
When Patroclus is exiled from hsi father's kingdom for inadvertently killing a boy and sent to Phthia, he's alone and terrified. At first, he goes unnoticed by basically everyone. When he first sees Achilles, the young Prince, he's enraptured but far too shy to say anything. He knows the story of Achilles birth. How his father, Peleus, overpowered the sea-nymph, Thetis, and Achilles was the result. The stories of his beauty and strength are not an exaggeration and Patroclus is in awe. Even more so when Achilles eventually notices him as well and decides that they will be companions and since he's the prince, he gets what he wants.
They are inspearable and what first begins as a friendship, soon turns into something more. Patrcolus is constantly at Achilles' side and no one seems to mind, except for Thetis, Achilles' mother. She despises Patroclus, thinking he's nothing more than a foul, foolish commoner/mortal and unfit for the likes of her son. But Achilles defies her by keeping Patroclus at his side.
When Helen, the most beautiful woman in the world, is kidnapped from Sparta and spirted away to Troy, Agammemom calls upon all the men of Greece to fight with him and rescue her. Though boys both know the prophecy, as told to them by Thetis, that Achilles will die at Troy, they join the fleet anyway. It's the threat of dying in obscurity, of never being remembered for his skills that terrifies Achilles enough to join Agamemmnon and the other Greeks. They appeal to his vanity and that arrogance, his assurance that he is the best of the best, will, of course, eventually be his downfall. And always the faithful friend, Patroclus never leaves his side, even though they both know how this story will end.
I was pleasantly surrpised at how closely Miller stayed true to the source of The Illiad. It's been a very long time since I read that particular story but from what I remembered, the few parts that were exaggerated or skewed slightly by Miller to fit into the story of Achilles and Patroclus relationship actually worked rather well. Though there were definitely parts that were overdone and full of romance cliches, overall, this was an entertaining read and a unique take on the background of one of Greek Mythology's greatest heroes.
Ended here.
Patroclus is exiled to Phthia when he inadvertently kills a boy. He is fascinated by Prince Achilles. Eventually Achilles decides that he wants Patroclus as his companion. And thy fall in love, much to Achilles’ mother’s displeasure. Shes a Goddess, Thetis and she has it out for Patroclus.
They go to the mountains together and train under the tutelage of Chiron tbd Centaur. Achilles excels in combat, of course and as years pass, he and Patroclus grow closer.
Achilles gather summons him back to the castle when Menelaus raises his army to sack Troy, Thetis spirits Achilles away to Scyros, since she doesn’t want him to fight in the war. Patroclus manages to follow him.
He poses as a woman but Theyis forces him to marry the princess and consummate the marriage. She becomes pregnant and the King says that the child will take Achilles name.
While they’re waiting for the Princess to have the baby, Diomedes and Odysseus come to Scyros. They know Achilles and Patroclus are there and they speak with them.
They appeal to Achilles arrogance, saying that yes, he can avoid the war but then he’ll be nothing, left to be forgotten and old, lost in obscurity. Achilles is horrified at the thought and so he agrees to go. Though Thetis his mother, reveals the prophecy that he will die at Troy.
They don’t know when but they know it will happen after he’s killed Hector. Patroclus and Achilles goodie, they can avoid Hector and shirt the prophecy. When they eventually sail on Troy, and the raids begin, Patroclus asks Achilles to take as many as the women that are captured as he can, to try and keep them safe. This is how he they come to have Briseis and she and Patroclus form a working friendship, interesting.
After a month of raids, Priam calls a parley and Menelaus and Oddysseus go. Priam explains that Helen has asked for his protection and he has never refused to protect a woman, so the next day, the real fighting starts.
When the war finally does start, Achilles is of course a marvel but he has no plans to face Hector, saying, so far, Hectors done nothing to him personally.
The way goes on for years. Patroclus begins helping it the medical tent and becomes quite important. Thetis shows up and explains that the Gods are taking sides and that they must side with Apollo. She also explains that there’s been another prophecy. That the best of the Myrmidons is one who will die first, Achilles will die after. They try to puzzle out who the best of the Myrmidons is since it’s not Achilles but they’re stumped.
It’s obviously Patroclus.
Achilles pitches his fit and refuses to fight when Agammemnon shames him in front of the entire army and his sulking, even when the Trojans break through their lines and start burning their ships, is ridiculous but that is what happens in The Illiad. When Patroclus pleads with him, that if he won't fight, then let Patrcolus fight in his stead and it of course, ends with Patroclus' death, well, Achilles is devastated. He kills Hector and all the rest and is eventually klled by Paris.
In a surprising twist, Thetis helps Patroclus' spirit find peace by writing his name into the monument that was built for Achilles as well. He's allowed to enter the Underworld and is reunited with Achilles. So, though they both die, in the end, it's a happy ending for the two lovers.
Comments
Post a Comment