Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke

 "Natalie Heller Mills is #blessed. Her Instagram account, Yesteryear Ranch, paints an idyllic picture of life on the farm with her family, full of photos and videos of home cooked meals, a loving husband and kind, calm, obedient children. Through the filtered lens of Instagram, she seems perfect, so of course, whenNatalie awakes one morning to find herself in the same house but everything is off.  The children are not her children, the house is older, dirtier and there's no modern amenities, such as electricity or running water. And her husband Caleb is now a gruff, stern, serious man.  It would appear that she's been swept back in time to the original Yesteryear ranch, to try her hand at living the traditional life she's always posting about. This book had all the hype but honestly, to me, it did not deliver." 

⭐️⭐️

Pros: The story did catch me and kept me intrigued enough to finish the book because I needed to find out what on Earth was going on. 

Cons: Natalie was one of the most unlikable protagonists I’ve come across in a long time. She was judgmental, cruel and selfish/I felt like the “explanation” for the time disparity was extremely glossed over and barely even explained. 

Full Review: 

Natalie Heller Mills is a traditional house wife and an influencer. Through her posts on Instagram, she shows her life on their idyllic farm, Yesteryear Ranch in Idaho. She paints a picture of perfection., home cooked meals, time spent with her obedient, loving children and romantic moments with her husband Caleb. 

She’s an extremely devout Christian, always thanking God for her children and this life she has. Though in all honesty, the farm hands do most of the work, her children are educated and raised by their two Nannies and she and Caleb are distant. She's obsessed with maketing and expanding her brand, making herself a household name. Though her posts are pictures of happiness and gratitude to the Lord, her actual life isn't all that perfect. 

On the night that her Producer, Shannon, resigns, her husband Caleb, decides it's time for him to run for Office, to follow in his father's footsteps and become a Politician. Natalie's thinks it's a wonderful idea, since she's been working with her father-in-law to put the idea into Caleb's head and as he announces his plan, they decide to pray on it. 

When she wakes up though, everything is different. Her children are not her children. The house is not as modern and updated as it’s supposed to be and her husband is now stern, terse and quite ready and willing to hit Natalie when she tries to run away, since she's convinced she's been kidnapped.  

As Natalie tries to orient herself in this new “present” we learn more about her past. How she and Caleb met and got married. How Caleb’s father supported their purchase of the farm, thanks to his oodles of money and how Natalie’s life has never been as perfect as her followers think. 

Though the plot had promise and the hope for a reasonable explanation or perhaps the transition of Natalie into an actual, likable, relatable character kept me reading, it never delivered. Through everything she continued to be a hypocritical, judgmental, selfish, cruel, uncaring woman who would do anything and everything to get ahead. Once the time disparity was explained and the whole story was wrapped up, I felt deflated and disappointed. I wanted Natalie to change, to learn but it felt like she never really did.  

Though this book was definitely a quick, entertaining and thought provoking read, my intense dislike of Natalie and her complete lack of redeemable qualities made it a relief when I finished it, so I wouldn’t have to read more of her snide, condescension and hypocrisy. This book had all the hype but in my opinion, it epically failed to deliver. 

Ended here. 

Though turns out her husband and her producer were having an affair. The producer resigns on the same night that her husband announces he’s going to run for office. His father’s a shoe in for President, so he might as well try his hand. They pray on it and she asks God to give her husband a spine cause she’s sick and tired of him borrowing bees. 

Wow. Just wow. 

The present - She wakes up in the frontier days. Thinks she’s been kidnapped. Husband promptly smacks her and puts her to bed. 

She thinks about the past. College. How no one was a believer. How her roomie was a whore. I think she’s a wicked judgy bitch but then I’m figuring she’ll change her mind and her ways if she returns to modern day? I’m hoping cause she is like, super judgy Jesus Bitch. 

She meets Caleb and they eventually go to dinner and then after like 3 dates, they decide to get married. Caleb is filthy rich and though it’s obvious his mother is just a side piece and Wino, Natalie doesn’t seem to care. She had shared her dream of having a farm, a family, a quiet peaceful life devoted to God and apparently Caleb wants that to. Well, that didn’t seem to work out too well for you Natalie cause your husband was screwing your producer, Shannon. 

Back in the 1800s, Natalie learns that the oldest child’s name is Mary and she’s horrified. That’s what they were going to name the baby in the present. 

Whine Natalie again tries to run, she makes it to the woods and promptly steps in a bear trap. Yikes. Caleb brings her home and Mary stitches up Natalie’s mauled ankle with good old needle and thread. Ugh. 

As she’s in bed with fever, she dreams, of having baby after baby, and get daughter Mary, who does NOT pull any punches. Like that girl is all business, 

Natalie remembers her wedding night. Then she runs into her old college roomie and gloats. God is she a bitch.

When she has her first child, Clementine , she can’t shake the feeling that the girl is evil. Her mother is also psycho, having her jog around the hospital the day after giving birth. Like.. what? These people are…messed up. 

Back at Yesteryear ranch, she comes back to Gerald and Is still there with a mauled foot. She decides to try and make friends with Maeve for asks her to come feed the chickens. The Ladies, which is what she calls them in her vids. In the way to the coop she finds what she thinks is a piece of broken microphone in the ground. Hrm. 

We learned more about Natalie’s past how she gets her father-in-law to give her $5 million to buy a ranch so she and Caleb can try their hand being farmers. It all starts horribly. The animals die like no one’s happy it’s awful but the photo she puts on Instagram or obviously happy and you know I love life.

But their marriage is so bad that they can’t feel like he can’t get hard enough for them to have sex so she just dumped the cereal bowl in his stomach and she’s like I don’t care how you get it done just get it done and then she takes a turkey baster like no lie. This woman is fucking nuts. 

When she hires a college drop out, Shannon, to be her Producer, things start to change. The night they attend a rally for Caleb's father, who's announcing his run for Presidency, Shannon is, to me, understandably horrified at the crowd. It's very MAGA, Trump, lemming, mindless idiots chanting America, America, Civil War. It's disgusting, truly. 

Soon, things start to devolve and eventually, Caleb admits to Natalie that he and Shannon are together. When Natalie goes to confront Shannon, she ends up trying to strangle her and when Shannon agrees to do an interview about the her assault, she paints a picture of Natalie as having tried to rape her, and so, since Caleb and his family are just as idiotic, brainwashed Christians as all the rest of their mindless sheep, they're more horrified that Natalie might be a "Queer." 

Also, since Abigail, Natalie's sister has gotten divorced, she's started seeing a therapist, as has her mother. Natalie's horrified, a therapist, my God, how modern and terribly against God's plan. Like, what the actual fuck is wrong with this woman? 

Basically, the whole thing with Natalie thinking she's in the past is a lie. After all the assault allegations from Shannon, and her suing them, Natalie and Caleb decided to basically, give up. They went completely off the grid. Clementine took the children and went to live with Natalie's mother. And Caleb and Natalie decided to live as if they really were homesteaders in the wild days of the old frontier. Natalie gives birth to Mary, then three other children. And when Maeve, the youngest falls sick, she goes to the neigbors house, to call on a doctor and it turns out that it's her son Stetson, listening to a radio and chilling with a beer. This whole thing has been one big orchestration of insanity. 

Clementine eventually shows back up and takes the children away. Natalie and Caleb decide to leave the ranch. Five years later, Natalie's serving a thirty year sentence for four counts of child endangerment (far less than she deserves, the hypocritical, condescending, judgmental, Aryan Nazi bitch). And she decides to give an interview with her past college room-mate Reena. It starts with Reena handing her a book, that was written by her daughter, Mary, the first child she had after she and Caleb decided to live the frontier life. 

In the prologue, Mary forgives her mother and says that she loves her. So Natalie gets away with it all. 

A truly disappointing read with a disgusting, unlikable, skin-crawlingly judgmental, egotistical, psycholitc protagonist. I hate that I wasted my time in actually finishing the damn thing. Ugh. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Kissing the Sky by Lisa Patton

Prototype (Archetype #2) by M.D. Waters

The Underground Railroad by Colson Whitehead