Piper at the Gates of Dusk (New World Trilogy #1) by Patrick Ness
“When giant skeletal creatures start rampaging through the land and abducting young people, all of New World is threatened. Ben and Max, Todd and Viola’s sons try and solve this horrifying mystery and save everyone. It was basically the story of the Pied Piper only on another planet. It was a quick, tense, exciting read and I'm eager to see where the series goes.”
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Pros: I liked Ben for his logical, rational mind, trying to see all sides of a situation/Max was genuine and tough though full of doubt and uncertainty/Though things have improved, sadly people are still people and will always have their opinions and prejudices.
Cons: The whole situation with the Land felt repetitive from the first trilogy but it was to be expected. Different generation, same issues/Burly’s monologue in the Marketplace after the violence with the Land was very poorly timed, like there were far more important things to focus on at that moment/The epilogue was ever so cliche.
Full Review:***Discliamer - If you've not read the original Chaos Walking triology (The Knife of Never Letting Go/The Ask and the Answer and Monsters of Men) I suggest you go and do so and then come back and read this at your leisure. That way you'll know what I'm talking about.***
There's a new generation on Old World. After the life atlering events of the original Chaos Walking triology, the settlers have more or less, settled. Most live in town, close to where Haven once was. Todd has decided to live further out into the woods and start his own farm and family. He and Viola are now married and have two children, Ben and their adopted son, Max.
Things were difficult when the settlers first arrived, Noise being the main struggle but they managed to create a cure and they gave it to all the children. For the most part, it worked but for a rare few, like Ben, it caused a neurological issue wherein he is now mute. He cannot speak and so, he uses sign language and his communicator to get his point across but he's constantly frustrated since this paints him as a forever outcast.
He and Max are quickly growing up, rife with the emotional upheavel and uncertainty of being teenagers. A new danger emerges when, a giant, skeletal, flaming creature staggers from the woods, screaming and grabbing for them, until it stumbles into the river and disappears. Also, Viola and the other Scientists have discovered a strange rock that's moving closer and closer to the planet and will arrive in only a matter of weeks.
Is this mysterious rock and the "Gods" connected? That's the real question.
Of course, the mayor, Burly, decides to use those of the Land that live and work amongst them as his scapegoat, much to Todd/Viola/Ben and Max's chagrin. He blames all this strangeness on them, spewing nonsense about them infecting them all with a virus, infecting the children with terrible nightmares about Noise. When the Sky appears and starts working with Todd to try and figure out what these creatures are and what kind of threat they pose, the townsfolk are suspcious and uncertain.
He shows Todd, in the Conversation, events that transpired more than a thousand years ago. It's basically the story of the Pied Piper, who led the children away and kidnapped them when the parents refused to pay what they owed. The events are eerily similar and when more "Gods" start appearing and chaos and mayhem ensue, it's up to Todd, Viola and their children to try and save the world, yet again.
This was a quick, entertaining and thought-provoking read. I liked both Ben and Max for their own personal struggles and Todd's relationship with them was genuine and good. Though there were parts that were a bit repetitive from the first trilogy, that was to be expected and I was able to look past it. The ending was pretty predictable but it left off for a sequel and, we all know I'll be reading it when it's published. All in all, this was an interesting addition to Ness' Chaos Walking world and I'm eager to see how things unfold.
Ended here.
New World Trilogy
Ben, who is the son of Viola and Todd and his adopted brother Max see a giant burning creature lumbering towards the end of the woods. It tries to grab them misses and then falls into the lake.
During all this, Ben’s arm is broken, so Max goes to get his dad and Ben realizes that he can hear noise from the water which doesn’t make any sense.
Todd patches up pens arm, and Viola comes back from the city. She’s on the city council and as a scientist Todd chooses to live on the farm away from other people. It’s been years since the settlers arrived and they created a new cure so most people don’t have noise, but Todd has chosen to keep his noise, which kind of makes him an outsider.
The cure had a strange effect on some of the children making it so their brains and vocal cords didn’t connect. They were able to cure most of the children, but unfortunately, they were not able to cure Ben so he is mute.
Todd speaks to the land about the giant burning creature, even as Viola comes back and says that they’ve seen a ship heading towards the planet. And apparently the night they saw the ship children started having nightmare nightmares, including Max.
While the land tells them a story, that’s basically myth about another strange burning creature rising from the Earth. It’s apparently supposed to warn you about arrogance, patience, you know not being a bad person, but he didn’t think it was true. Apparently it is though and that’s when they hear a scream. They run outside and the giant burning creatures there again. It smashes through their farm and then falls into the lake once more.
They go to the city where things are still a bit tense with the settlers and the Spackle. When one of the teachers lets them see the asteroid in a telescope they all wonder what it’s about. Later on, the mayor, a man named Burly, talks to Ben and Max, saying that he thinks the rock coming towards them is a ship and it means invasion.
Todd immediately brings the boys back to the farm as they rebuild. The Bouse dreams that everyone but Ben are having is all anyone can talk about. It all comes to a head when the Sky comes to their house in the city and relays the story of the Pied Piper to Todd. He tells Burly why thinks it’s all rubbish but Todd explains that it’s a warning. Something is coming for the children.
It’s decided that Max will go with Todd, who’s off to find Ben, like old Ben, even though he doesn’t want to ruin his happiness. Ben will stay in the town with his mother and attend his classes. Turns out this is the worst mistake they could have made.
Todd and Max go out into the woods and eventually find Ben, older Ben. He’s chosen to become one with the land because he can see Killian in the conversation and so he kind of just stays there. He saves Todd and Max from a Rine, like a bear. The go and search of the town where the story that the Sky told them about is.
On the way it’s revealed that there is a cure for the cure. Max is a didn’t since Todd was saying that he regrets having given the boys the cure wondering if it’s changed to they are who they’ll become. Apparently driven a wedge in Todd and Viola’s relationship as well so there’s that .
They eventually find a giant rock in the middle of the woods with a lightning shaped cleft in it. They hear a scream like what Max and Ben heard when they first saw the God, but Todd says it’s the wind. He wonders if there’s another opening but land Ben says there’s not. So they wonder what the hell they’ve found.
Meanwhile, Ben Young Ben is taking classes in the city. Be less frustrated because she can’t figure out what’s causing the dreams and how to help the kids that are having them. Young Ben still doesn’t tell her that he’s not having the dreams.
Terra a classmate of his ask him to come for a walk with her. And she admits that she saw a God last night she saw it rise up from the woods and watched it throw itself in the water and she says she knows where it came from and she asks Ben to come with her.
There was surprised to find Arrow who’s also looking for the God because it took his sister echo last night. He followed them to the river and dove in, but they just disappeared. None of the adults believe him and so he’s gone off by himself to try and find and kill God. And Tara and Ben join him. They end up finding another rock, just like the one Max and Todd have found. Tara and arrow explain that they feel like this rock has been here their whole lives, but they have no memory of it ever being in the woods. So that’s strange..
Arrow decides to start climbing the rock and when he gets to this zigzag opening, that’s when the screaming starts. Flames reach out and grab Arrow and pull him into the rock and the flames run down the rock and form into a God.
Tara and Ben run like Hell and manage to dodge to and climb up a hill just in time to see that the God is rampaging right for the city. The God rampages through the city and during the chaos, Burly and Margaret Wyngard take their chance to ambush and kill Spackle in the marketplace, even as Tara screams at them to stop and that they’re all insane. Burly starts saying that the only way they’ll have peace is to keep a common enemy in the Spackle 🙄. The god swoops down and picks up Taper and disappears into the water. And then, they realize that there are now 7 Gods all standing around the city, looking up at the sky.
The Land God kills everyone. Even Ben. His death was a hard scene but done well. The Sky comes and investigates to rock with Todd and Max. They realize that the rock must have come from the ship that’s coming towards the planet. Like a plant taking root. When it’s shown that the city folk attacked and killed Spackle when the God rampaged through the city, the Sky leaves them, saying that this is their problem and he will not have anymore of his people killed for the people’s sins:
Ben and Max race back towards the Cify in hopes of being able to help Viola and Ben. The God take Tara and Ben is rescued from the river by Wilf and his mom. And she’s figured out that the Gods are made of noise. Someone’s figured out how to attack them with the thing they cured. Interesting.
They manage to tie vials of the cure to nies and arrows and defeat a few Gods that way. And the Sky shows up Kidd in the nick of time to save them all. He’d said to Max that a person is who they become by the choices they make and when Todd asked him for help again, he reminded him of what he’d told Max and so, the Sky chose not to become like the humans. He chose to be better.
While the Land is operating on Todd, who got stabbed by the idiot Margaret Wingard, the Glyph shows up. If hovers in the air for a moment and then starts shooting out smoke and all the young people are still taken. Well that sucks.
But Ben is not taken and he’s of course, furious that they took his brother so, it ends with literally, something along the lines of, “now they’re gonna pay.” I guess a little cliche is allowed. Definitely left of a cliffhanger.
Comments
Post a Comment