Mad Mabel by Sally Hepworth

"Elsie Fitzpatrick is quite content to live a quiet life, tending her garden, reading her books, and spending time with her best friend Daphne. The peace is soon shattered when her neighbor is found dead, and Elsie is the unfortunate one to discover the body. A news story is soon published, revealing the dark truth of Elsie's past as "Mad Mabel" Victoria's first convicted female murderer at the ripe old age of fifteen. What follows is an often heart-wrenching but also hilarious tale of found family, love, and the truly unbreakable power of friendship."

⭐⭐⭐⭐️⭐

Pros: Mabel is a saucy beast, and I liked her immediately/Beneath all that irreverence is a woman capable of great love and devotion/Hepworth was great with pacing and suspense. 

Cons: The "big reveal" at the end and Mabel's "inheritance" just seemed rather extraneous. 

Full Review:

Elsie Fitzpatrick is a crotchety, sarcastic, 81-year-old woman living on a small street in Australia and minding her own business. She tries her best to stay under the radar and not call attention to herself. Most of her time is spent with her best friend, Daphne, and neither of them minds the quiet life. 

When Persephone, the daughter of a single mother named Roxanne, asks to interview Elsie for a school project, Elsie tries to avoid it. She's not a big fan of children, especially Persephone, who's loud and obtrusive. When Elsie mentions Ishaan, her 91-year-old neighbor, explaining he'd be better suited for the task, Persephone says she can't interview him because he's dead. 

When Elsie knocks on Ishaan's door, no one answers, and so she climbs the back fence and sees that he is, in fact, lying dead on his kitchen floor. Well, that's unfortunate. 

The police are called, and since Elsie found the body, they question her. She explains that she never liked Ishaan;  he was, in fact, her nemesis in a way, since he never took care of his dog Nugget, letting it bark all day and make a mess of her yard. She doesn't think anything will come from the interview until an article is published in the newspaper, claiming that she, the infamous Mad Mabel, is on a killing streak once again. 

Well, that's troublesome. 

The simple fact is that yes, Elsie and Mabel are one and the same. She was the youngest person to ever be tried and convicted of murder in Australia. She's done her best to get on with her life after all that hullabaloo. Now she's been thrust back into the spotlight. She agrees to give an interview to two YouTubers, telling her side of the story in hopes that it will cut the head off this media beast and keep it from escalating. 

Things start to change, though, when a man begins appearing regularly on the street, looking for Roxanne and acting all around suspect. Elsie, though she's loathe to admit it,  has started to like Persephone, and so she agrees to help Roxanne with this troublesome man, the best way she knows how.

Mabel was a complicated character, having had a lonely and difficult childhood with parents who found it hard to show affection. Secrets were kept, resentments built, and honestly, when the truth was finally revealed, I totally understood why Mabel did what she did. In Mabel, Hepworth has created a funny, irreverent but honest character, and the pacing and flow of the story were absolutely spot on. There's no wonder this book is a "hot title. I absolutely devoured it.  

Paused here.  

Right off the bat, Mabel is a crass, funny woman. She's 81 years old but doesn't fit the stereotype of "frail, old lady." She's six feet tall, broad shouldered, is more apt to call someone dipshit isntead of dear and doesn't go to the bank to talk to an "actual person", she in fact, adores the conveinence of the ATM. 

She's been living on the same street for her entire life and is determined to stay there. One morning, someone slips a note under her door. She thinks it's her nosy neighbor, who lovest to complain. Instead, it's a photocopied news article, and Mabel turns it to show Daphne, saying simply that, someone knows. 

She and Daphne are best friends, not lesbians, but the kind of platonic female friendship that not many people have ever experienced. And Daphne's such a close friend that, Mabel would easily kill for her, and I'm thinking, perhaps she did. 

Intriguing. 

When a neighbors daughter, Persephone asks to interview Mabel for a school project, since she has to talk to someone old, she says that Ishaan, her neighbor is 91 and should be the one being questioned. Persephone says he’s dead, since he didn’t answer the door and after Mabel scales the fence, she sees through his sliding doors that yes, he is, in tact, dead. 

Then…

Mabel is the only child of affluent parents. Rosehill, their giant estate was always home to epic parties. Her mother was often drunk and her father was distant. At one party; a guest sits with her for a moment and asks her if it’s lonely: it must be after Kitty. Mabel doesn’t know whom she’s talking about and her father soon sends her off to bed. She overhears them talking and her father says that they don’t talk about Kittty. Not in front of Mabel.

She was often bullied for her height, red hair and penchant for books. She doesn’t  know when she was given the nickname of Mad Mabel but it seems to be appropriate, since her father even admits that there’s something not quite right about her. 

She adores feet aunt Cess and her aunts friend, Ness. They take care if her when herb parents are traveling abroad. They convince her to start keeping a journal. So she does and spies on her parents party guests and that’s how she sees her father screwing another woman against the wall. 

Present…

Ishaans dog, Nugget has decided to attach itself to Mabel, much to her chagrin. Persephone has also taken a liking to her. One day Mabel notices a shifty looking man in the street and Persephone running inside. When he asks Mabel if Roxanne lives in the street, she says no and Peter, her bricks and friend inadvertently gives it away that Roxanne does live here. He asks them to tell Roxanne that Shane was looking for her and leaves. Perhaps Persephones absentee father? 

The police come to Mabel’s door and ask her more about her relationship with Ishaan. She éxplains in no uncertain terms that she hated the man. They then take her shoe as evidence and as they’re leaving they say that it makes sense that she would’ve changed her name. Couldn’t go around calling herself Mad Mabel after all, though they’re surprised that she didn’t move and start a new life. Apparently they know who she is as well. 

Hrm, 

Turns out her parents did have another child. Kitty. And when Mabel contracted Polio, Kitty contracted it too and died. Sadly, her father seems to blame her for Kittys death. Mabel finds out about this when she’s in hospital, having broken multiple bones at a summer camp. As she’s healing, her mother visits every day. 

Mabel is terribly lonely and decides that like Anne of Green Gables, she’ll find herself a bosom friend. Like Cessa and Nessa . 

 One day she wakes up to see that her mother is still there, in the clothes from the day before. She explains that her father is going on a trip to London, with another woman. Mabel explains that she saw them once at a party and explains what they were doing. Her mother smacks her and then promptly throws the door to her private hospital room open and launches herself over the railing of her private balcony. Jesus. 

Now…

New crews are starting to show up after an article is published about Ishaans death, painting her as a suspect. Two YouTubers approach her for an interview and she eventually agrees. Since she can’t really sue anyone for defamation, she figures shedding light on all the “to do” might cut the head off the beast. Persephone has also become more of a presence, breezing in unannounced and she sees something in Mabel’s back room that Mabel doesn’t want her to see. Hrm. 

Then…

Her father has left and she returns to Rosehill with Cess and Ness. Cess hates her father as much as Mabel does. Her only friend from Kindergarten, Daphne, has moved back to Australia and they realize they’re going to the same school. She’s found her bosom friend, which makes me happy though I do wonder if she’ll end up killing her father, since before her YouTube interview the woman that is running it says she’s the only 15 year old in Australia history to be convicted of murder. 

She gives part of an interview to the Youtubers, but it is interrupted by Persephone at her door who wants to show her how she can swing a hula hoop around her neck. As she’s watching this a group of college age, kids approach and one of them lifts what looks like a gun. Mabel finds herself covered in. Blood falls back, breaks her wrist, but nothing else serious it was more of a demonstration than an attack, but she did push Persephone behind her so she has a soft spot for the girl.

At the hospital where she gets her wrist bound up Persephone is also been checked out and she wants to sign me’s cast which she does but her mother Roxanne is very adamant that they leave now, so somethings up with that. 

Then…

She becomes friends with Daphne, who is her friend in present day. They see a bonfire on the beach and they go to socialize with their peers. There’s a boy there who starts basically knocking Mabel talking about kitty and how Mabel killed her and then killed their mother pushed her off the balcony and Mabel finally knows what it feels like to wanna kill someone. 

Once Mabel is discharged from the Hospital, Roxanne, Persephone’s mother pays her a visit. She asks if it’s true, if Mabel is Mad Mabel and Mabel admits that yes. It’s true. Roxanne said that she can’t have Persephone spending so much time with her anymore. 

Then…

Mabel runs from the little shit that was harassing her and runs into one of her teachers. She talks to him and tells him what the other kids have been saying. Cess calls her home and the Teacher, Mr. Loukas tells her that he thinks she’s amazing. Later that night, the parents of the boy who was harassing Mabel knock on the door and ask where their son is. Mabel says she ran from him and doesn’t know what happened after that. A police car shows up and they’ve found the boy, Billy.  He’s not dead but has a serious head wound and has been put in an induced coma. 

Now…

Persephone sneaks onto Mabel’s porch and they talk through the window. Persephone asks her why that man shot her with the water gun and Mabel explains that, some people form opinions of others without knowing all the details. Persephone explains that she’s lonely and wants a friend and thought Mabel might feel the same. Ugh. Tugging on the heart strings. Mabel’s starting to warm up to the field. Later that night Shane, the Italian Stallion bangs on Roxanne’s door and Persephone comes out. Mabel swoops to the rescue, explaining that she’s the babysitter and luckily, a siren sounds and Shane pauses, giving Mabel enough time to swoop Persephone inside and shut the door. 

Then…

Mabel and Christos, a new boy to town, walk home together and he apologizes for not stopping Billy. She has a bit of a crush as they part ways. A few days later, Mabel attends a vigil mass for Billy.  Billy will be woke from the coma next week to see if he has permanent brain damage. Also, hopefully find out what happened to him. “He” walks up to Mabel and takes her outside and then to a small nook where he kisses her. You hope it’s Christos but no, it’s Mr. Loukas. She’s smitten cause she’s just a child and he asks her to meet him there again, same time next week. Sighs. Fucking creep. 

Now…

When Roxanne returns home after working, she cleans offices at night, since the pay is so good, she confesses to Mabel that Shane, the Italian Stallion is Persephone's father and though she has a restraining order against him, and has moved five times in hopes of eluding him once and for all, it's never quite panned out. Mabel, much to her own surprise, finds herself offering to baby sit Persephone on the nights that Roxanne has to work. Persephone can stay in her spare room (which is apparently a shrine to her neighbor Peter, I'm thinking perhaps he's her son, since she did have an affair with her teacher Loukas and the age difference may add up but I don't know that for sure yet.) 

Then...

Her father has finally returned home from his travels abroad. And though it's only been a few months since her mother's suicide, he's as taciturn and as much of a fuck as usual. He kicks Cessa out, saying he never wants to see her at Rosehill again and Mabel is left on her own with her dick of a Father. She's also started having an affair with Mr. Loukas, belieiving that she's in love. And maybe she is. 

Now...

She continues her interview with the two YouTubers but when two detectives knock on her door and ask her to come to the station to answer more questions about Ishaan's death, she agrees. Since she and Ishaan had had a tussle a few days before he died and he scratched her trying to get Nugget back, her DNA is beneath his fingernails and there's a spot of blood on her shoe from when she turned his body over in the kitchen to find a pulse. It's all rather damning and since the autopsy has been inconclusive and toxicology will take weeks, the police are viewing all angles, meaning Mabel. 

Luckily, the busy body neighbor Joan, who's always threatening to reveal the truth about Mabel, arrives just in time with her nephew who's a partner in a law firm, that she's constantly reminding people of. Her nephew is with her, there to help Mabel. Well, turns out Joan isn't such a bitch after all. 

Then...

The next morning after her father returns from his travels, Cess is serving them breakfast. She also serves Elliot with papers from their lawyer, stating in no uncertain terms that her sister, Mabel's mother, Mary's will says that in the event of her death, the estate of Rosehill will be left to her eldest child, when they come of age. And since Mabel is not yet of age, and Cess hsa been acting as her guardian while Elliot's been away, he'll have a hard time getting custody of Mabel. Cess is kicking Elliot out of Rosehill. I do love that woman. 

Though Mabel is terrified, since her father's parting words were, he'll get Rosehill if there are no surviving blood relatives of Mary, Cessa tells Mabel that she'll protect her, no matter what. And Mabel, hopeful, believes her. She wants to be protected and loved. And God in Heaven, I want the same for the poor girl. She's already been through enough as it is. 

Billy, meanwhle, has woken from his coma but doesn't remember the accident, thus, he can't point to who attacked him. 

Meanwhile, Mabel and Mr. Loukas continue meeting. All they do is kiss and Mabel feels rather dirty but a bit thrilled by it all. One day, while handing out fliers at the church, Daphne points to the stairs and Mabel sees her father, with Susan McGinty on his arm. It's only been months since her mother's suicide and already, he's flaunting McGinty around. She's not sure what he's planning to try and get around Cessa's plan but, she's frightened. Though Daphne says that if looks could kill, her father would be dead on the spot. 

Mabel and Mr. Loukas continue their illicit meetings, though they only kiss, until one day, in the sports shed behind the school, he puts his hand under her shirt and then, slides his hand up her skirt. They're interruped by Brother Stanislaus, the principal. Mabel manages to hide and Mr. Loukas explains that he was trying to get a basketball to shoot some hoops at home. Stanislaus gets him a ball and they leave, locking the door behind them, locking Mabel in. She at first thinks that perhaps Mr. Loukas will come and help her escape but he doesn't, so she manages to kick a corner out and crawl to freedom. 

Instead of going home though, she goes to Mr. Loukas house and the door is answered by a pretty woman. She asks Mabel whom she's looking for and silly Mabel answers honestly, saying she's looking for Mr. Loukas, uh oh.  

Now...

Joan's nephew, Bailey has managed to get the police to release Mabel and he drives her home. Mabel and Joan have an almost friendly discussion about how Joan admits that she's terrified of Mabel, having learned about her past but she might have been wrong. Everyone on the street thinks very highly of Mabel, especially Peter. And though Mabel is happy to hear this, she tells Joan that she thinks Joan and Peter could do well together, if she doesn't mind spending all her weekends at Aldis. I'm glad that they're not as hostile to each other anymore. 

Then...

Mr. Loukas' finacee is livid, saying that he'd had affairs with other students, younger and prettier students. Mabel is understandably crushed. While she's walking home, she flattens his tire. Good for her. Or course, the next day, it's announced that Mr. Loukas is dead. Crushed under his car when trying to fix a flat. 

Woops. 

Now...

Mabel wakes up on morning to find all of her neighbors standing on the street, looking at her house. She's confused but when she steps outside, Persephone, overjoyed, points to what's been painted on her house. The word Mad. 

Then...

With news of Mr. Loukas' death, more details are announced. Scratches on his neck and shoulders. And of course, Mabel's relationship with him is revealed. She tells Daphne about it and Daphne, ever loyal, calls him a snake. When they get to school there are two Police officers there, who take Mabel to the staiton in the city, saying they have parental consent, from her father, to question her. 

When she gets to the station, Cess is there, saying her lawyer will fight this. Mabel manages to break away from the officers and Cess, who literally climbs under the desk to get to her, embraces her and says in no uncertain terms and not quietly, that she's going to kill Mabel's father. Damn straight. 

During all of this, Mabel's reputation gets ever lower than before. She's thought of as a slut, a harlot and she's reviled by mothers and children alike. The only person, aside from Daphne, who defends her, is Christos. He's by her side, always. They often have lunch together and the first time they kiss, it's on a small beach in a cove and it's so different from when she would kiss Mr. Loukas. I have a feeling it's not going to turn out well but, well, maybe it will. 

Nope, I was wrong. Billy, who's been meaner ever since waking up from the coma, once cornered Mabel in the bathroom and put her hand on his crotch, saying that maybe she missed it. Digusting little pig. One day, when she's unlocking her bike, he's there. He tries to grab her and she shoves him backwards, but of course, Christos suddenly appears, Billy stumbles into Christos, who falls back and his head smacks against the pavement. 

Ugh. 

Now...

With this vandalism, Mabel realizes that her very presence is putting the lives of her neighbors in jeopardy and she doesn't want that. She's always tried to be a quiet, good neighbor and so, she decides to put her house on the market ;(. 

She's even beginning to enjoy her time with Persephone, who has a friend over for a play date and they decide to start calling her Grouchy Granny though Mabel suffers it all, even with some humor. 

This book is going to break my heart. 

Then...

Luckily, Christos does not die from bumping his head but his mother will not let him spend time with Mabel. She's crestfallen but she doesn't understand. Also, her Father's lawyers have been in touch, and he's making a case that he needs Rosehill in order to raise his family, since he plans to marry Susan McGinty, thus bringing her little daughter Amelia into the mix. And he plans on having Mabel in the house as well. 

Asshole. 

With that news, Mabel and Daphne go to Susan McGinty's house to see the lay of the land. They watch as Amelia plays in a tree. When her mother calls her in for dinner, Mabel sees her father come outside to help Amelia down. And though he has his hands stretched up, he doesn't catch her when she jumps. She breaks her arm, or is at lesat somewhat injured and her father is his usual bastard self, asking when dinner will be ready instead of worrying about his soon to be step-daughter. 

Mabel pedals away, knowing now that her father really is a monstet and that none of what's happened is really her fault. Cess and Ness are trying to fight her Father's case but they're not sure if they can. 

Now...

Mabel continues telling her tale to the YouTubers but they're running out of time. So, she continues and gets right down to the murder. 

Then...

On the day of the murder she'd biked home and found her father's car in the driveway. When she gets inside the house she can hear him yelling. She walks up the stairs to find the door to Cess' bedroom open and Cess and Ness are covered in a sheet. So they were lesbians. Mabel finds herself shocked but at the same time, frozen. Her father tells her to pack a bag, that they're leaving but Cess tells her to stay. Mabel runs off to the only safe place she can think of, Daphnes. 

She returns home an hour later, surprised tha ther father's car is still in the driveway. She lets herself in and finds Cess' door open just a bit. She picks up her father's umbrella, which was a gift from her mother. She finds her father standing over Cess' body, her neck broken. 

So what does Mabel do but bashes his head in with the umbrella. She hits him until her limbs give out. 

Now...

She ends her story and the YouTubers say that she confessed to killing her father but not to killing Cessa nd Ness defended her in this regard. They say that the papers say that her journal was very detailed about all things, the dates, the weather, about everything except for one thing. 

Daphne. 

Then...

She goes to Daphne's who says they have to fight but Mabel knows what will happen to her. So she doesn't. She simply leaves. 

Now...

It turns out that Daphne isn't even actually real. Mabel explains that she knows she's not real, she can't see, hear or smell her but to her, she's as real as she needs her to be and she's the one thing that's more or less kept her sane. The doctors called in Multiple Personality Disorder, as a way for Mabel to deal with all the trauma in her life but, Mabel doesn't argue. I didn't see that one coming but I guess it does make sense. 

Adeem and Libby, the two YouTubers, are finishing up their interview and they reveal that they know Mabel gave birth to a child while in the Psych hospital during her incarceration. They'd like to know who the father was and what happened to the child. 

Turns out Peter is her child. Knew it. Nessa had opened a home for single mothers and their children. When Mabel was released from prison, she would help out at the home. Nessa adopted one child, a young boy who was birthed by a 15 year old girl in a psych ward. Mabel. 

Mabel and Peter go to the watch party together, which is just a small gathering at Adeems house. When the documentary hits youtube it quickly goes viral. 

Mabel runs into Roxanne one day and she says that she's seen Shane. He threatened Persephone. And of course, a few nights later, Mabel wakes up to the sound of breaking glass and sees Shane with Persephone in her arms. She charges down the street and leaps in front of Persephone just as Shane pulls the trigger, thus killing Mabel. 

A legal loophole is found so that Peter, who is Mabel's son, inherits Rosehill. He gives a large amount of money to Roxanne and Persephone, who plan on buying a house with it. No mention is made of what happens to Shane. I'm assuming prison, for having shot Mabel. And though Persephone misses Mabel every day, her new friend, Daisy, tells her not to worry, that Mabel is with her because remember, after all, she was with Mabel every day too. Daisy is Daphne et cetera. 

This was a great book overall though Mabel's death and the existence of Peter, with Mabel having had a trust with Christos, because she mentions his father was Greek, just seemed extraneous. Yes, they kissed but, there was no mention of it having gone any further than that. 

Other than that though, it was a great book. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Kissing the Sky by Lisa Patton

Prototype (Archetype #2) by M.D. Waters

The Underground Railroad by Colson Whitehead