The Man Wife by Meaghan Church
"Lucy (Lulu) Mayfield tries to be the put-together, perfect picture of the good wife and loving mother she sees in all the magazines. She even has "Good Housekeeping's official schedule on how to keep a tidy house, on her refrigerator door. The truth is, though, most days, she struggles to work up the energy to cook, clean, raise a child, and have dinner on the table. Exhaustion is her constant companion, and when, one sleepless night, she sees lights on in the new neighbors' house, her curiosity is piqued. She's determined to find out more about the quiet, shy Bitsy Betser because she just has a feeling that she's hiding something. The truth she uncovers is earth-shattering. This was an emotionally charged, heart-wrenching tale of one woman's desperate plea to be seen, heard, and understood in a world where, sadly, women were better seen and not heard. I devoured this book and would recommend it to anyone who has ever felt overlooked or brushed aside
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Pros: I flew through this book, read it in two days. It was compulsively readable.
Cons: It’s an unfortunate truth that women were and sometimes still are expected to “play their part.” I’m glad I’ve never had an issue being honest about how I’m feeling, regardless of how it might sully my reputation/Lulu's "escape" in Part 2, I don't think, could have actually happened. Still, for the sake of the story, I understood why it did, but the security was horrifically lax.
Full Review:
Lulu Mayfield is the epitome of the 1950s housewife. Her hair and makeup are perfectly in place, all rooms are spotless, and dinner's on the table, with a drink for her husband as soon as he steps through the door after a long day at the office. She even has the schedule on how to keep a tidy home from "Good Housekeeping" on her fridge.
The truth is, that schedule is just a piece of paper and often overlooked. Lulu's been finding it more difficult to summon the energy to cook, clean, and do all the things a "good housewife" should do. She never knew how exhausting motherhood and keeping house would be. There were no classes to take, and her mother isn't the nurturing type, so she's had to try and learn all of this on the fly.
She has a few friends in her neighborhood of Greenwood Estates, the small piece of Suburbia she calls home. Nora and Hatti, whom she plays cards with once a week while the children nap. It's a small refuge where they can sit and talk about grown-up things without small ears to hear them.
Things start to change when Lulu realizes she's pregnant again and a new family moves into the house across the street. Once Lulu returns home from the hospital, her daughter Esther, a small pink bundle in her arms, she starts to wonder about the new neighbors, the Betsers. All of Lulu's attempts at being friendly are met with vacant, distant stares and short, staccato answers from the wife, Bitsy. Also, there are no pictures of Bitsy's beautiful daughter, Katherine, in her house.
Something just isn't sitting quite right with Lulu, but when she starts to dig deeper, she uncovers a truth that will literally make her world implode.
This was a compulsively readable, heartfelt, and heart-rending story of one woman's desperate fight to be seen and heard in a world where women are expected to simply be picture-perfect, silent dolls. It was a difficult and emotional story, and Lulu's frustrations and wish to simply be seen, heard, and understood had me both near tears and also furious at the horrific toxic masculinity of life in 1950s Suburbia. It was a poignant commentary on societal expectations and how damaging they can be, but through it all Lulu fought and stayed true to herself.
Ended here.
Part 1 - The Window
Lulu Mayfield tries to be a good house wife. Attentive to her son and husband. Keeping up with chores but honestly, most days she’s too exhausted to put on the happy face.
After the birth of their daughter, people start to worry. Especially when she starts having nausea, dizzy spells and fainting. Add to it her husband, always working and never really seeing her anymore. His solution to her blues is to buy her a dishwasher so she won’t have to do them by hand anymore.
Add the arrival of new neighbors across the street and Lulu’s life starts to go a bit sideways. Though she keeps up appearances, Lulu finds it harder and harder to play the role of the good housewife. And she can’t shake the feeling that the new neighbor, Bitsy, is a bit off.
Her doctor says she has “housewife syndrome” and gives her a prescription for Miltown, he says it’ll have her right as rain in a few weeks. Lulu doubts that but she tries it anyway.
When she’s over the new neighbors house, she sees that Bitsy isn’t as put together as she seems. Her bedroom is a disaster and in her bathroom is a prescription for phenobarbital. A powerful tranquilizer. Add to that the newspaper article of a woman that killed herself in Bitsys old neighborhood and Lulu starts to wonder. Is Bitsy hiding something?
Lulu sneaks across the street and lets herself into Bitsy‘s house because she has a spare key that Emily the last tenant left. She rifles in boxes and finds the newspaper article about the woman that took her own life. It turns out that that was Bitsys sister, and she left behind a daughter Catherine so that explains why there are no baby pictures of Catherine in the house.
Lulu then digs through more boxes and finds one called medical where there are discharge papers for Bitsy explaining that she has treatment resistant depression and the best procedure is a lobotomy signed off by her husband. Lulu, Nora and Hattie had mentioned a woman that had had a lobotomy when playing cards a few days ago and how awful it wasx Lulu knows the truth because Bitsy was acting strange when they were talking about all that.
Dear Lord, what men will do.
Bitsy catches Lulu at the door. She uses the cat who’s been visiting her at night, Luna to distract Bitsy saying that perhaps that’s how the cat got out. For now she appears to be safe.
Everything goes sideways after Henry asked her to throw together dinner for him and his boss. That night when she’s nursing Esther the cat Luna creeps in and climbs her lap. She wakes up in the morning and apparently Esther is dead. She freaks out understandably and well, Henry is trying to restrain her. The whole neighborhood is watching and she tries to explain that Gary made Betsy have a lobotomy. Catherine isn’t her real child, but then the breeze blows moving pretty bangs in. There are no scars on her forehead from a lobotomy. I don’t know how long Esther is supposed to have been dead. But Lulu was obviously unwell.
Part 2 - The Mirror
Henry takes her to the sanatorium where she’s given a room of her own and he simply asks her to remember. To rest and get well as if a nap will cure everything.
She tries to remember Esther‘s birth, but things are a little fussy now she remembers wrestling saying that he’ll be the best big brother ever but after that now she’s not so sure. She was too focused on spying on Betsy, the neighbors across the street that she doesn’t remember losing a baby.
I’m also not sure what happened, this book has definitely been a roller coaster.
Well, in the sanatorium meeting with Dr. Rutledge, Lulu admits that she didn’t always believe that Esther was not there. She thought she was there. She knows that she’s going to play the obedient role of calm, quiet patient in hopes that Rutledge does not give her a lobotomy.
She remembers Esther’s birth now. How she did deliver but sadly, Esther was already did, most likely strangled by the umbilical cord.
When Henry comes to have a session with her and Dr. Ruthledgw, the doc suggests ECT, thinking Lulu is a good candidate. She doesn’t want it but Henry doesn’t resist the doctor. And mind you this is back in 1955. All I can think of is “One Flew Over the Cuckoos Nest.” Gah. 😳.
Nora visits her and tells her that she has to shake herself out of this and save herself if she doesn't want to turn out like Bitsy. So, Lulu takes Nora at her word and decides, that after a session with Ruthledge and Henry when it's decided that she'll have to receive more ECT to further her "healing" she decides to just walk out the front door, take Henry's car and drive to her childhood home.
That was the one part of the book where I knew, for a fact, it wouldn't have happened. Even in the 1950s, you wouldn't have been able to just walk out the doors of a mental hospital but for the sake of the story, it had to happen.
She returns to her childhood home and for the first time in her life, her mother actually runs to her, in concern. Poor Lulu.
When her mother gets a good look at her, she simply says, "The wolf's got you too" and for a moment, I was afraid that Lulu's mother had lost her mind as well. But, as it turns out, the disesae that eventually took her father, is the same one that Lulu has, it's Lupus. A disease that I'm sure was, and still is, commonly misdiagnosed.
She stays the night in her childhood bedroom and in the morning Henry shows up. They sit under her favorite tree and she explains that she's not going back to the hospital. Though she thinks Henry will try to fight her, eventually relents and when he finally, FINALLY asks her what she wants, she simply says, "She wants her" meaning Esther. They have a moment where they hold each other and cry because, it wasn't just Lulu that lost her daughter, Henry lost her too.
Ugh.
She returns home and starts getting treatment for the Lupus, though it never fully goes away, as autoimmune disease don't. But she returns to her life and her friends on Twyckenhem Road in Greenwood Estates. Norah is her usual brash self, Hatti has her baby and they both survive the colic and the Betsers end up moving away. It was an acceptable ending, actually, a deep and poignant one to a hard hitting but deep and emotionally charged book.
Comments
Post a Comment