The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides
"It's been six years since Alicia Berenson was tried for the murder of her husband, Gabriel, and sent to the Grove, a facility for the criminally insane. Theo Faber, a therapist, has just transferred there, eager to work with Alicia and try to get her to open up, to actually speak, after six years of absolute silence. Michaelides kept me guessing, and the twist at the end was pretty surprising. Though this wasn't the best mystery/thriller I've ever read, it did keep me on my toes."
⭐⭐⭐
Pros: I was curious to see why/if Alicia killed her husband. The chapters were short, which I appreciated since they offer convenient stopping points.
Cons: Everyone is in love with Alicia, of course/It all escalated rather quickly.
Full Review:
Alicia Berenson is a moderately famous artist. Her husband, Gabriel, is a fashion photographer. They’re a seemingly happy couple. That is, until Alicia is found with her husband, who’s been tied to a chair and shot five times at point-blank range in the face. Alicia has cut her wrists and is rushed to the hospital and saved.
She’s put on trial for the murder of her husband, but she never speaks a word. She’s found guilty and is sent to the Grove, a mental health facility for the criminally insane.
Theo Faber is a psychotherapist who’s given up a solid career and transferred to the Grove, hoping to work with the famous Alicia Berenson. Six years have passed since the trial, and she still hasn’t uttered a single word.
Theo is determined to crack the case and figure out what will make Alicia speak again. He starts digging around in her personal life, contacting friends and family. She's struggled with mental health issues since childhood. Alicia survived a car accident that her mother did not. When her father killed himself, Alicia also attempted suicide, not out of grief but, apparently, because she hated the man.
None of it makes much sense, but Theo is determined to learn as much as he can about Alicia and try to break her silence. Even as his own life begins to unravel, he's devoted to Alicia and figuring out what is behind that silence.
The ending caught me off guard, but I appreciated how Michaelides untangled all the threads and smoothed everything out. I must say, I was pretty surprised at how things turned out.
Ended here.
Part One.
It starts with a diary entry of Alicia Berensen, saying that her husband Gabriel had grifted her this notebook as a way to write down things, thoughts, ideas, feelings. And she's determined to keep it as just a notebook for happy, positive thoughts since sometimes she's plagued by depression.
The next chapter, we learn that she's been tried and convicted for the murder of her husband, even though in the diary entry she says that she loves him so much, it's almost overwhelming.
The night of the murder, she's found with a knife in hand, having cut her wrists to the bone. There was also a gun on the floor and Gabriel was tied to a chair and had been shot in the face, several times.
She never speaks a word. Not through the whole trial and when she's sent to a Psychiatric Institute to serve out her sentence, she continues her silence.
Theo Faber is a Psychiatrist and is a little bit obessed with Alicia Berenson. When he was younger, he struggled under the overbearing, physical beatings of his father, who was always angry. He tried to kill himself but it didn't work and he realized that he wanted to live. His first therapist, a woman named Ruth, was the one who helped him start working though his issues and he's determined to meet with Alicia Berensen and get her to talk.
He manages to get a job at the "Grove' which is the nickname for the hospital where Alicia is serving her sentence. He's learned that she survived the car accident that killed her mother. He's sure that had an impact on her as a child.
He notices that she's heavily medicated and still, doesn't speak.
But he's determined to crack her open and get her to talk to him.
Part Two
A slew of diary entries from Alicia, explaining about a heat wave and how she's painting a picture of Jesus, that apparently she's put Gabriel's face on it. So she asks him to pose for her and she notices that she can't get his eyes right. In life, they sparkle, are entrancing but in the picture, they're cold and emotionless.
Meanwhile back at the psych ward.
Theo thinks he'll be able to get Alicia to talk to him if they lower her medication dosage. They do so and she promptly attacks him. But he's determined, saying that even now, she's speaking, since rage is a powerful emotion.
Since the Grove is under intense scrutiny and the Trust is threatening closure, the director, Diomedes, gives Theo six weeks to get Alicia to talk. Since she's a famous patient, it might give them the sway they need with the Trust to stay open.
Theo feels up to the challenge.
He meets with Gabriel’s brother Max. In her diary, Alexis explains that Max assaulted feet at one point and of course, makes a move on her again before the murder, saying he loves free.
Theo also meets with her cousin, Paul and get aunt, Lydia. In her diary it turns out that Paul was in trouble from Gambling and she gave him 20K to avoid the loan sharks.
Theo meets with her Gallerisr, Jean-Felix and is a bit repulsed by him. In her diary it turns outs that Alexis was planning on changing Galleries and Jean Felix was upset because of course he’s in love with her.
This is quickly turning into an “everyone is in love with Alexis” thing. Typical.
Also, Theo like’s to get stoned when his wife is away asnd he discovers that she’s having an affair because he reads her email.
When Alicia explains to Gabriel that she's told Jean-Felix she wants to change Galleries, she admits that she's afraid of Jean-Felix.
Theo's had the great idea to give Alicia her own painting space. He gets her easel/brushes/paints from Jean-Felix and sets her up in a spare room in the hopsital. The first painting is the hospital, on fire and Theo has Alicia in his arms, but he's not sure if he's rescuing her or throwing her into the flames.
Disconcerting.
Meanwhile, Barbie, Alicia's old neighbor stops by the ward for a visit. They wont let her in but she invites Theo to her house later that night. She explainst that she and Alicia used to talk all the time and that one afternoon, Alicia admitted that she was afraid. That she felt like someone was watching her. She texted a photo of a gray, blurry something behind a tree. It could be a man, a tree, God knows, and the cops dismissed it as inconsequential.
When Theo leaves he wonders what Alicia was afraid of and if someone really was watching her. He of course, feels eyes on the back of his head and turns but no one's there.
I started losing track of the Parts.
All the threads come together when it turns out that Theo, is actually the man that Alicia thinks is stalking her. He's been following Gabriel, who's been having an affair with Theo's wife, Kathy. He follows Gabriel home one night and then, the next day, is standing there, having snuck into the back yard. He hears the door opening and hides in the shed, which is, of course, Alicia's studio.
Lo and behold, Theo grabs Alicia, ties her to a chair, waits for Gabriel to get home, knocks him out, ties him to a chair and then demands he decide whether Gabriel should live, or if Alicia should. Will he choose himself over his wife. And as Theo counts down from ten, Gabriel finally says that he doesn't want to die.
So all Theo does is drop the gun and untie Alicia's hands. She heard it all and he's left her the gun, basically saying, look at what your husband did, he chose himself over you. So, I'm just leaving the tools you need to punish him. And she does, she shoots Gabriel.
Then, she realizes that it's Theo who's her new doctor. It all got a bit confused but, she eventually realizes that Theo was the man who was following her. So, she writes a last entry in her diary, admitting that Theo inject her with the morphine, that he ODed her and that he's guilty.
She slips into a coma and after everything settles down, Theo is promoted to the head of the new psychiatric ward. But, of course, the police eventually find the diary, shoved into the corner of the painting she made of Theo and her, with the hospital on fire.
It was a pretty good ending, I definitely wasn't expecting it and though the timelines got a little confusing, in the end, I was pleasantly surprised with how Michaelides wrapped everything up.
Comments
Post a Comment